A review of faulkners a rose for emily

The room we see is dominated by a crayon portrait of Emily's long dead father on a tarnished gilt easel. The town's actions reveal callousness, viciousness, hypocrisy, meddling, and a general inability to understand the meanings of events. Even though the townspeople seem, for once, to do the decent thing by not opening the room until she is buried, they have pried enough to know that the door will have to be forced.

Mysteries about Emily's actions remain unsolved: We have seen that the story focuses on the relationship between Emily and Jefferson; specifically on the ways in which the town interprets and acts on the information it gathers about her. Homer disappears and the town is morally triumphant.

The cousins leave town. Whatever the case, I think that she wanted more from their relationship than he was willing to give and rather than suffer his absence from time to time, she made sure he'd stick around.

By this time she is fat and her hair is short and graying. Nicklaus Happel, for example, believes that the narrator is somewhat aloof from the town and that, in the course of his narrative, he shows sympathy for Emily to atone for past neglect. Yet, even though we tend to take Emily's part against all tax collectors, mailmen, and busybodies, we are not required to sympathize with and admire her without qualification.

If it offends your sensibilities, however, you may want to miss-out on this one. In general they are wrong -- as it is almost certain that they are wrong about the cause of the smell and the fact of the marriage.

Her victories continue into part four, when she vanquishes the Baptist minister and when the town's female-relations strategy backfires.

William Faulkner

Some months later, when Emily appears again in public, her hair has been cut short, she has grown fat, and her hair has turned gray. The body is not identified, nor is it in an attitude to indicate a violent death from arsenic.

Whereas the older generation felt that sending their children to Emily to learn china painting was a duty or obligation like sending them to Sunday School, the new generation does not even feel the obligation. As we witness these confrontations, we seem to learn much about the town, but relatively little about Emily.

Another pair of paragraphs precedes the first dramatic incident. The story is so constructed that we sympathize with Emily without understanding her, whereas the town, thinking it understands her, is shown to lack sympathy.

Looking at these sentences from the story: Comedy and the Purpose of Humor," Arizona Quarterly, 16 Spring60, thinks that Emily takes Homer in defiance as a father-substitute, then kills him to insure possession when he threatens to leave her.

In part five the town is completely in control. Emily's funeral is over before the story begins, and the last scene of the story is in the past tense.

It strengthens our suspicions about the causal relation of the poison, Homer's disappearance, and the smell, but does not confirm those suspicions.

Though it is not really clear whether stereotyping is a cause or an effect of lack of sympathy, it seems rather clear that the problem with the categories is that they falsify their object, making sympathy difficult.

A Rose for Emily

Although the second paragraph seems to move our attention from Emily and the town to her house -- a house such as we often see in Gothic Romances -- we are shown a similar set of antagonists. Faulkner, who dislikes masculine women, thus has an opportunity to analyze her necrophilia.

She is dignified and powerful as she vanquishes them. Emily was trapped in a web of aristocratic mores, but was denied the love that she needed.

The generations are similar in that they both choose to deal with an idea of Emily, rather than with Emily herself; they are different in that they have different ideas of her and, therefore, approach her and her taxes differently.

Because he drove away all prospective companions, when he dies Emily goes into a state of unreasonable denial, because then she was truly alone it must be noted that there was no indication that her father was involved in any incestuous relationship with her—her father drove away all the young men who courted her because they were deemed unsuitable by her father, who harbored extreme aristocratic arrogance.

No one sees Emily for approximately six months. Mar 14,  · “A Rose for Emily” is an important element in literature due to examination of the effects of change created in the olden South.

This story serves a good example for future generations. Works. "A Rose for Emily", by William Faulkner, is a southern Gothic horror story that reveals the disastrous romance between Emily Grierson and Homer Baron.

Despite a lifetime of repression under Emily's tyrannical father, who denied all of her would be suitors, Emily.


Homer, absent from town, is believed to be preparing for Emily’s move to the North or avoiding Emily’s intrusive relatives. After the cousins’ departure, Homer enters the Grierson home one evening and then is never seen again.

Holed up in the house, Emily grows plump and gray.

A Rose for Emily Summary

Sep 01,  · "A Rose for Emily" was an enjoyable Southern Gothic short story. In a series of flashbacks, the narrator tells the reader about Emily's life. Emily was alone in the world because her father had driven away all her suitors/5.

User Reviews

Download-Theses Mercredi 10 juin Oct 08,  · In "A Rose for Emily" by William Faulkner, we see how past events effect the main character Miss Emily, especially her mental state. She seems to live in a sort of fantasy world where death has no real meaning.

A review of faulkners a rose for emily
Rated 4/5 based on 28 review
A Review of Faulkner's A Rose for Emily | Essay Example